Urgent Life-Threatening Conditions in Lockdown Shanghai Demand Prompt InvestigationComments Off on Urgent Life-Threatening Conditions in Lockdown Shanghai Demand Prompt Investigation
Nearly two months since the mega city Shanghai has been put under rigid lockdowns aimed to achieve “Zero COVID”, disturbing eyewitness videos and stories continue to surface on social media, depicting residents living under desperately life-threatening conditions as a result of the Chinese government’s draconian pandemic control measures.
The crisis is not confined to Shanghai – the central city of Zhengzhou announced lockdown measures from May 4-10 and Beijing has identified over 500 restricted areas with corresponding travel restrictions on residents.
CHRD urges the Chinese government to save lives from unnecessary deaths, protect human rights, especially international human rights conventions with respect to COVID-19 prevention, and to be transparent about the numbers of infections and deaths – both COVID-19 related and other preventable deaths.
While CHRD has not been able to independently verify all of the online videos and reports, given the notorious state censorship imposed on the Internet and restricted access by foreign reporters on the ground, cumulatively, the information filtering out online strongly suggests the situation in the besieged city dire.
Some of the most shocking incidents include:
- Hu Hong, a woman who was a former Fudan University literature student, was found dead in her apartment from apparent starvation. According to a series of screenshots from a group chat by former Fudan foreign language students, she may have died due to not being able to receive medicine for high blood pressure. She apparently died with just a bowl of rice left in her home to eat.
- A video that surfaced on May 1 from Jiwang Township of Minhang District in Shanghai showed many people out on the streets in protest and attacking the police. The narrator of the video says that they have been in lockdown for 45 days and have nothing to eat.
- In another video, an old man stops a truck along the Huqingping Highway in Qingpu District to say, “Shanghai people, not one person cares about us. Take care of us! Expose this! Help me expose this! I am a worker. I’m going to starve to death!” The couple in the truck gives him bananas and crackers, and the man broke down crying with gratitude.
- On May 1, Rights Defense Network warned that a human rights defender, Xie Baolan, a migrant worker from Anhui, had been in lockdown since April 3, and her electricity and water were cut off starting from April 25. They warned that there was no way to get food supplies to her.
- A woman, a migrant worker in her 50s, had no choice but to live in a phone booth for over a month during lockdown. She was expelled by police from the phone booth on April 29.
- An elderly person was put into a body bag and taken to a morgue, only for the workers onloading the body from a vehicle to find that the person was alive. According to a statement issued by Shanghai officials on May 2, four officials have been punished and the patient is in stable condition.
- There have been many videos of incidents of resistance to the draconian policies, which are probably just the tip of the iceberg. In one video, nearly 20 officials in “white suits” (police and other government officials in PPE) storm the door of an apartment complex to take away a woman and place her in quarantine, and one of the officials is heard yelling “you are not allowed to film”. In another, a “white suit” police officer breaks down a woman’s door to take her into quarantine and tells her to stop filming. In another video, four white suits try to capture two elderly women with a long metal rods with tongs at the end. Eventually the women escape control as onlookers can be heard cheering their bravery.
- There have been other videos of Shanghai residents committing suicide, in apparent desperation (viewer discretion advised, see here, here). Or in another viral incident, a woman in Shanghai threatened to jump from a building in order to secure food as she yelled that she was “starving to death”.
It is urgent and obligatory that Chinese authorities immediately alleviate the still unfolding humanitarian crisis. The Chinese government must promptly lift state censorship on the press and online media, allowing independent investigation and efforts to seek official accountability for any preventable deaths and for unnecessary human suffering.
CHRD is concerned that such efforts by affected residents, local human rights activists and lawyers to seek accountability will be stifled. Chinese authorities have punished vocal critics of its lockdown measures. For instance, on April 30, an online citizen journalist, Ji Xiaolong, was taken away by ten police officers after Ji had persisted in his social media reports of the Shanghai lockdown and his criticisms of the “Zero Covid” policy’s worsening impact on Shanghai people. Most notably, on April 2, Ji wrote an open letter addressed to government leaders, “Quickly End the Mass Movement Style Anti-Pandemic Work and Relieve our Difficulties, and Send Supplies – a Shanghai Citizen’s Request on Behalf of the People”. Ji was released the next day on bail and forced to pay a fine of 1,000 RMB yuan.
Besides attempting to coerce people like Ji Xiaolong from expressing their views of the lockdowns through detention, the authorities have engaged in widespread online censorship blocking or deleting social media messages, audio or video recordings, depicting life and death in Shanghai, or airing discontent, voicing dissent, as CHRD has previously reported. Behind the information blockade, the situation on the ground could be much more desperate than what little is known to the outside world.
As United Nations human rights experts have made clear, the countries that make use of emergency powers granted by the COVID-19 crisis should only do so very carefully and should not use such powers to “quash dissent”. The UN experts stressed that “…we urgently remind States that any emergency responses to the coronavirus must be proportionate, necessary and non-discriminatory”.
The nearly two-month long lockdown in Shanghai are unproportionate responses, especially when effective vaccines have already been developed, and in light of the fact that the lockdown measures more severely impact the lives of migrant workers, the elderly, and those with other health condition or in need special assistance.
And yet, despite the urgent need for a change to COVID policies, it is unlikely to happen in the near term as the government doubles down on its policy that is increasingly making little sense. On May 5, the Standing Committee of the Politburo of the Chinese Communist Party met to discuss the latest COVID situation. The meeting, which was chaired by General Secretary Xi Jinping, declared that “from beginning to end [we must] maintain a clear head, and absolutely unswervingly maintain the general policy of “dynamic Zero COVID”, resolutely unite in cutting off misrepresentations, doubts, and engage in struggle against words and deeds of those who oppose Our Country’s anti-pandemic general policy”.
Responding to this development, CHRD’s Research and Advocacy Coordinator William Nee said:
“Committing to “struggle” against people desperately calling out for food, water, and medicine is absurd and will not change the dire situation on the ground. The government should launch a prompt investigation, figure out what has gone wrong, and change its ways before more lives are lost”
“It is absolutely appalling that Shanghai, normally one of the world’s most efficient commercial metropolises, has been paralyzed for months. The Chinese government should immediately provide assistance to all those in need – especially the elderly, the disabled, and migrant workers,” Nee added.
Renee Xia, Director (Mandarin, English), +1 863 866 1012, reneexia[at]nchrd.org, @reneexiachrd
William Nee, Research and Advocacy Coordinator, CHRD, +1-623-295-9604, William [at] nchrd.org, @williamnee